64 Holstein calves stolen in ‘highly coordinated’ Ohio livestock heist
Mercer County Sheriff investigates the theft of 64 Holstein calves worth up to $128K. Officials warn of a potential black market amid record cattle prices.
www.farmanddairy.comHere’s a concise update on the recent Mercer County calf theft situation.
-
Summary: Authorities in Mercer County, Ohio, investigated the theft of 64 Holstein calves from a Coldwater-area farm, occurring overnight between May 2 and May 3, 2026. The calves were about 13 weeks old and weighed roughly 250 pounds each. This incident is being treated as a highly coordinated cattle theft, with investigators noting the perpetrators likely had prior livestock handling experience. [Sources from local outlets and national coverage confirm the scale and timing of the theft.][1][3][5]
-
Likely motives and aspects: The theft involved calves docked tails, suggesting familiarity with dairy operations and possible use of a black market or resale channel. Authorities have issued requests for tips and are circulating descriptions and photos to auctions and dealers in the region.[3][5]
-
Current guidance for locals: If you have information, contact the Mercer County Sheriff’s Office or the listed tips lines in local coverage; rewards or public-private collaborations may follow as the investigation progresses.[5][6][3]
-
Related context: Similar high-profile cattle thefts have been reported in Ohio around the same period, underscoring concerns about livestock security amid rising cattle prices.[4][5]
If you’d like, I can pull a short, cited timeline of events or summarize the key outlets with direct quotes. I can also help you watch for updates from specific outlets or set up alerts.