‘All Her Fault’ Review: A Gripping Domestic Mystery Anchored by Strong Performances
Michael Peña stars in this eight-part thriller centered on the disappearance of a 5-year-old boy from a wealthy Chicago neighborhood. Marissa Irvine (Sarah Snook), the desperate mother at the heart of Peacock’s All Her Fault, insists,
“We’d do anything for our kids. Anything.”
Her words carry the weight of a parent willing to make every sacrifice to protect her missing son, Milo (Duke McCloud). Yet the series also explores the realities behind that fierce devotion—the exhaustion after repeated tantrums, missed bedtimes due to work, and the painful truth that no amount of care can shield a child from all harm.
Exploring the Fragile Line Between Protection and Control
The mystery delves deep into these emotional cracks, following Marissa and her husband, Peter (Jake Lacy), as they confront the nightmare of Milo’s disappearance. While the show doesn’t quite reach the heights of other renowned domestic thrillers like Big Little Lies, it remains engaging with smart plot twists and sharp insights into maternal guilt, paternal pride, and the fine line between wanting to protect a child and needing to control them.
For much of the story, the actual truth of what happened to Milo seems almost secondary to the unraveling emotional and psychological struggles the family faces.
Key Themes and Performances
- Strong portrayal of a desperate mother by Sarah Snook
- Clever narrative reveals keeping viewers engaged
- Insightful commentary on family dynamics and parental flaws
- Michael Peña and Jake Lacy support the emotional weight of the story
All Her Fault is a satisfying addition to the genre, combining suspense with nuanced human drama.
“We’d do anything for our kids. Anything.”
Author's summary: This series offers a compelling look at a family’s struggle with a child’s disappearance, blending suspense with incisive observations on the complexities of parental love and control.